Zodiac Discussion Forum

smokie treats
smokie treats
@smokie-treats
Noble Member
Joined: February 19, 2015 10:34 pm
Topics: 5 / Replies: 1621
Reply
Re: Evidence of transposition misalignment in the 340

Wouldn’t the probability of the plaintext aligning into pivots, no transposition involved, be exactly the same as the probability of pre – route trans…

10 years ago
Reply
Re: Evidence of transposition misalignment in the 340

Doranchak, somewhere you discussed at length the probability of finding two plaintext pivots in a 17 x 20 rectangle, and then the probability of encod…

10 years ago
Reply
Re: Evidence of transposition misalignment in the 340

I’ve put forward a test cipher in this thread that has 5 skipped characters. Here’s what it looks like when I perform the test that looks for skipped …

10 years ago
Reply
Re: Evidence of transposition misalignment in the 340

Here is an example of what three skipped plaintext will do to the readability of an untransposed message. Very simple inscription rectangle 17 x 20, …

10 years ago
Reply
Re: Evidence of transposition misalignment in the 340

Yes to the post above. Maybe a structure and not just a few skips or nulls. I have thought about this idea before. A 22 x 15 rectangle, except altern…

10 years ago
Reply
Re: Evidence of transposition misalignment in the 340

Jarlve, I did some work on this idea. See the third post down here: viewtopic.php?f=81&t=2617&start=1330 I spent some time on the 340 today. …

10 years ago
Reply
Re: Evidence of transposition misalignment in the 340

I’m mindblown and need some time with this, it looks very promising. I applied your transposition to a plaintext and then mirrored it and a few things…

10 years ago
Reply
Re: Evidence of transposition misalignment in the 340

As I said in the other thread, maybe the pivots are an intentionally planted clue. That would be very Zodiac like. Maybe he put the pivots in the mess…

10 years ago
Reply
Re: Evidence of transposition misalignment in the 340

I highly recommend reading The Department of the Army Technical Manual ( published 1955 ), pages 18 – 26 here:

10 years ago
Reply
Re: Evidence of transposition misalignment in the 340

Step 1: Transpose plaintext. The inscription and transcription rectangles are both 17 x 20 to keep things really simple. I inscribed left right top bo…

10 years ago
Reply
Re: Evidence of transposition misalignment in the 340

Jarlve, you might also want to check out my experiment with smokie38 where I tried to transcribe around column 9 to create period 29 repeats: About t…

10 years ago
Reply
Re: Evidence of transposition misalignment in the 340

I agree. For what it is worth, my heatmap shows that deleting symbols in the area of the pivots would increase the count of period 30 repeats. On…

10 years ago
Reply
Re: Route Transposition and Phenomenon

When I say cut by the edge of the message, I mean that the two symbols of a period n bigram occupy different rows in the message. For example, period …

10 years ago
Reply
Re: Route Transposition and Phenomenon

Here are the period 5 repeats, that when the message is read right left top bottom or left right bottom top become period 29 repeats. That’s part of t…

10 years ago
Reply
Re: Route Transposition and Phenomenon

Simply the 340 is less cyclic because he was trying more to not repeat symbols in rows or some similar window, instead of keeping with the cycles. ? …

10 years ago
Page 57 / 109