Complete amateur hour experiment anyway. Should have played Nancy half a dozen voices and told her to pick one.
Wasted opportunity. Cheers!
Nancy heard many voices of many suspects. Common knowledge to those who do a little research before posting opinionated and erroneous nonsense.
Does Nancy designating RG’s voice makes any more sense than, say, Mageau pointing to Allen’s picture among several others? 
Does Nancy designating RG’s voice makes any more sense than, say, Mageau pointing to Allen’s picture among several others?
Yes. A voice is audio, not visual.
Does Nancy designating RG’s voice makes any more sense than, say, Mageau pointing to Allen’s picture among several others?
Yes. A voice is audio, not visual.
Thanks, I didn’t know that…
To me that doesn’t mean her memories were clearer. I couldn’t tell my own mother’s voice if it was presented to me among several others.
We may not be convinced by either statement but we aren’t in any position to dismiss them. Both hold interest respectively.
Does Nancy designating RG’s voice makes any more sense than, say, Mageau pointing to Allen’s picture among several others?
Yes. A voice is audio, not visual.
Thanks, I didn’t know that…
To me that doesn’t mean her memories were clearer. I couldn’t tell my own mother’s voice if it was presented to me among several others.
My point is, it is reasonable to think that Zodiac sounded similar to Gaikowski or the actor who played Allen, based upon what Nancy stated.
For example, Rick Hoffman sounds similar to Gaikowski. Rick Marshall sounded less similar. Ted K even less so. It would be helpful if we had a magic device to hear the voices of all the key suspects.
I couldn’t tell my own mother’s voice if it was presented to me among several others.
Then you aren’t very bright.
My point is, it is reasonable to think that Zodiac sounded similar to Gaikowski or the actor who played Allen, based upon what Nancy stated.
For example, Rick Hoffman sounds similar to Gaikowski. Rick Marshall sounded less similar. Ted K even less so. It would be helpful if we had a magic device to hear the voices of all the key suspects.
Then you could only compare those POIs’ voices between them. The miracle would be if Zodiac’s voice had been recorded, of course. The case would be long closed.
I couldn’t tell my own mother’s voice if it was presented to me among several others.
Then you aren’t very bright.
Come on, Tom, you know you shouldn’t go down that path 
Here is a thread from Tom’s forum on Zodiac’s voice: http://www.zodiackiller.com/discus/mess … 1151042280
Includes clips from Nancy Slover imitating the voice and answering questions. Surprisingly, she says that Bruce Davis’s voice was "close" to Zodiac’s. Closer than Allen’s.
I know that video. To me it only says that Zodiac had a deep voice. So had Gaikowski. Does that mean Gaikowski was the Zodiac? Certainly not.
I know that video. To me it only says that Zodiac had a deep voice. So had Gaikowski. Does that mean Gaikowski was the Zodiac? Certainly not.
Did I say that? No, I said Gaikowski was a reference point to what Zodiac sounded like.
I know you didn’t, my friend, I’m just saying that all we know for sure is that Zodiac had a deep voice.
As for intonations and other personal characteristics, that’s a whole different story.
I know you didn’t, my friend, I’m just saying that all we know for sure is that Zodiac had a deep voice.
As for intonations and other personal characteristics, that’s a whole different story.
Okay, but I imagine the cadence of Gaik’s speech did remind Nancy of Zodiac to some degree.
I know that video. To me it only says that Zodiac had a deep voice. So had Gaikowski. Does that mean Gaikowski was the Zodiac? Certainly not.
What video? It’s a link to a discussion thread.
Hilarious how Nancy’s statements about Gaikowski’s voice are underplayed here. We all know if she had said the same of Ross Sullivan, a bunch of you would wet yourselves.
